Britney Spears has responded to claims made by fellow singer Kelly Clarkson that she might have faked her infamous 2007 mental health breakdown – during which time she was filmed shaving all of her hair off and attempting to smash a paparazzi's car window using an umbrella – for publicity.

To recap, in 2007 Britney's declining mental health triggered concern amongst fans and the following year she was hospitalised under a temporary psychiatric assessment ruling later being placed under a conservatorship which allowed her father, Jamie Spears, to control her freedom and finances.

But, just weeks before the singer was placed under the conservatorship, American Idol winner Kelly Clarkson made comments in the press that suggested Britney might have faked the ordeal. "Man, but wouldn’t it be funny if she’s just totally screwing with everyone?" she said during an appearance on The Bert Show "Because it'd be real funny if she were like, 'Just kidding!'"

britney spears on claims she faked 2007 breakdown for publicitypinterest
Mark Sullivan//Getty Images
Britney in 2007.

Later in the interview, Kelly went on to point out the timing of Spears' Blackout album, which had been released around the same time. "I mean, think about it. She’s done no press for her album — which I love, by the way," she told the show's hosts. "She's done no press, just gets so much press off all this other stuff."

Now, almost two decades on, Britney has called out Kelly over her comments, taking to Instagram to give her opinion on the suggestion she might have faked her breakdown for publicity. "I don’t forget… don’t you just wish she would say she’s kidding???" Britney wrote in a now-deleted caption on Instagram. "Clarkson… in a world where bullying has been heartbreaking, I’ve had my share… Can we get an AWW??? Psss… I’m not kidding… play on friends, play on!!!"

But in the comments section, Britney fans weren't so keen on her decision to call out Kelly, with some pointing out that the American Idol winner had defended her on many other occasions. "Kelly was repeatedly asked to say nasty things about you in 2007-2008 and not only didn’t take the bait, but called you hot and complimented your music," one person commented, as someone else said: "If you’re talking about Kelly Clarkson this is so unfair, she was defending you, always has. If you took the time to watch the full argument she gave, you’d know."

Here's hoping these two can work things out with each other...

Headshot of Jade Biggs
Jade Biggs
Freelance Writer
Jade Biggs (she/her) is one of Cosmopolitan UK's freelance writers, working across all sections including entertainment, beauty, body, and sex and relationships. She previously held the position of Features Writer, covering everything from breaking news and the latest royal gossip, to the health and fitness trends taking over your TikTok feed. Jade has a degree in journalism and has been a journalist and content editor for ten years, interviewing leading researchers, high-profile influencers, and industry experts in that time. She is a cat mom to four fur babies and is obsessed with Drag Race, bottomless brunches, and wearing clothes only suitable for Bratz dolls. Follow her on Instagram, Twitter, and LinkedIn.