Skip to Content

Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story characters vs the cast in real life

Here's what they look like out of character

By
lyle and erik menendez
Netflix

Ryan Murphy is back on Netflix with the latest edition of the Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story series and season two will deep dive into the case of the Menendez brothers Lyle and Erik, but what do the cast look like in real life?

The nine-part series tells the complex case of Lyle and Erik who killed their parents José and Kitty in the summer of 1989. While the brothers have always maintained that years of abuse was the reason they chose to kill their parents, the prosecution argued they were after the family's fortune.

And before you deep dive into the series, here's everything to know about the characters of the series, who plays them, and crucially what they look like in real life.

1

Lyle Menendez

lyle menendez
Netflix

Lyle Menendez is the eldest brother of the Menendez brothers and was 21 years old when he killed his parents.

2

Nicholas Chavez

nicholas chavez
Unique Nicole//Getty Images

Lyle is portrayed by 25-year-old Nicholas Chavez. Nicholas is best known for his role as Spencer Cassadine in General Hospital.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
3

Erik Menendez

erik
Netflix

Erik Menendez is the younger Menendez brother and was just 18 years old when he killed his parents.

4

Cooper Koch

cooper koch
Leon Bennett//Getty Images

Erik is played by 28-year-old Cooper Koch. Monsters is Cooper's biggest role to date, but he's also known for appearing in Swallowed, A New York Christmas Wedding and They/Them.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
5

Kitty Menendez

kitty menendez
Netflix

Kitty Menendez is the mother of Lyle and Erik, and wife to José. She was 47 years old when her sons killed her.

6

Chloë Sevigny

chloe sevigny
Getty Images

Kitty is portrayed by the iconic Chloë Sevigny, who you'll probably best know for her roles from American Psycho, Big Love, Zodiac, American Horror Story and most recently in Ryan Murphy's Feud: Capote vs The Swans where she played C.Z. Guest.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7

José Menendez

jose menendez
Netflix

José Menendez is the father to Lyle and Erik, and husband to Kitty. He was a music industry executive and was 45 years old at the time of his death.

8

Javier Bardem

javier bardem
Leon Bennett//Getty Images

Javier Bardem plays the role of José, and has of course been on our screens for years, with memorable roles in Skyfall, No Country For Old Men, Being The Ricardos and Dune amongst many, many others.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
9

Dominick Dunne

dominick dunne
Netflix

Dominick Dune is the Vanity Fair reporter who covers Lyle and Erik's trial.

10

Nathan Lane

nathan lane
Charley Gallay

Dominick is played by Nathan Lane, who you'll most recently recognise from his role in Only Murders in the Building. He's also known for his roles in The Gilded Age, The Producers, The Birdcage and crucially as the voice of Timon in The Lion King.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
11

Leslie Abramson

leslie abramson
Netflix

Leslie Abramson is a defence attorney, who becomes the lead counsel for Erik in his trial.

12

Ari Graynor

ari graynor
Steve Granitz

Leslie is played by Ari Graynor, who easily has one of the biggest hair transformations in the series. Ari is best known for her roles in The Sopranos, Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist, Whip It and many more.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
13

Judalon Smyth

judalon smyth
Netflix

Judalon Smyth is the mistress and ex-patient of Erik's therapist Dr. Jerome Oziel, and ends up having a pretty crucial role in Lyle and Erik's arrests.

14

Leslie Grossman

leslie grossman
Kevin Winter//Getty Images

Leslie Grossman plays Judalon in the series and equally has a pretty dramatic hair transformation for the role. Leslie has appeared in many series of American Horror Story and is also known for her roles in Love, Victor and Popular.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
15

Dr. Jerome Oziel

dr jerome oziel
Netflix

Dr. Jerome Oziel is Erik's therapist who he begins to see after his parents' death.

16

Dallas Roberts

dallas roberts
Roy Rochlin//Getty Images

Dallas Roberts takes on the role of Dr Jerome, and he's best known for his roles in movies Dallas Buyers Club, 3:10 to Yuma, and the TV series The Good Wife.

Watch Next 
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below