After more than a year of waiting for a resolution on *that* jaw-dropping cliffhanger, Tell Me Lies returned for Season 3 this week. The show blessed us with not one, not two, but three new episodes—and I couldn't be more excited to tune into TV's most toxic couple every Tuesday. If you're not too distracted from cringing over Lucy's life choices or eye-rolling at Stephen's manipulation tactics, you might have noticed that the show delivers some pretty epic Y2K-inspired looks (coconut bras included).
Most of the show is set in the late 2000s, which means there's plenty of nostalgic fashion to drool over—think ultra-low rise jeans, lace-trimmed camis, and the occasional Ugg boot. Ahead, I'm breaking down the best outfits from Tell Me Lies Season 3, including some exact pieces worn by our favorite puswas.
This killer sequins and fur combo
When I was in college, I pretty much refused to wear coats in fear of "ruining" my going-out outfits, but this adorable fur jacket is making me rethink my choices. Lucy goes a little more glam for the ski-themed party, pairing her vintage Bebe coat with a silver sequin tank top from Jaded London that's miraculously still in stock.
Jaded London Sequin Lace Cami Top
V-Neck Sequin Top
Steve Madden Kindra Coat
Edikted Livia Double Belt Low Rise Jeans
GRLFRND Laurie Belted Mini Skirt
This elegant bridesmaid look
Season 3 picks back up on Bree's wedding day, and somehow, we're left with even more questions than before. While the drama unfolds, Lucy at least looks like the ideal bridesmaid in an off-the-shoulder satin gown from Bec + Bridge, which is still available to snag for any upcoming nuptials.
Bec + Bridge Eternity Off Shoulder Maxi
Azazie Emerson Off the Shoulder Dress
Ettika Freshwater Pearl Linear Drop Earrings
Blue Ocean Pearls Strand Pearls Bracelet
Dolce Vita Serlo Ankle Strap Pump
These festive frat party 'fits
To be fair, an après ski-themed frat party is probably the only appropriate place to wear a Fair Isle tube top. While Diana's exact piece appears to be vintage, you can channel her vibe with this printed Skims tank and some plaid stockings. Meanwhile, Pippa's Diesel cutout top is sold out (tragic!), but you can recreate the look by layering a black shrug over a red tank top.
Bolero Shrug
Square Neck Tank Top
Abercrombie & Fitch Scarlett Curve Love Vegan Leather Mini Skort
SKIMS Fair Isle Cami Top
A New Day Bias Plaid Tights
These nostalgic layers
The early 2000s were all about layering, and these winter-ready outfits are shining examples. Bree is giving main love interest in a Nora Ephron movie with her oversized bomber and knit scarf (I'm still obsessing over her haircut), while Pippa plays with texture by layering a cropped utility jacket over a ribbed top and leather mini skirt.
Abercrombie & Fitch Vegan Leather Bomber Jacket
Aonal Cable Knit Scarf
By Anthropologie Faux-Suede Twofer Jacket
Madewell Ribbed V-Neck Sweater Top
Coach Outlet Ashton Bag
This laid-back denim outfit
Personally, my favorite Lucy outfits are the most simple ones, like this layered T-shirt look styled with some classic blue jeans. In an episode of Call Her Daddy, Grace Van Patten revealed that she wears True Religion denim in the show—and she may have stolen a pair from set.
Free People A Little Bit Layering Top
EDIKTED Wendy Tie Back Lace Camisole
H&M Ribbed Sweetheart Top
Gap Extra Low Rise Jeans
True Religion Stella Low Rise Skinny Fit Jeans
This ultimate throwback moment
Honestly, is there anything more biblically accurate Y2K than flatironed hair, an army green coat, and a Tiffany charm necklace? Her exact jeans are likely vintage, but this bootcut Abercrombie & Fitch pair is pretty damn close (and they're on sale!).
Tiffany & Co. Double Heart Tag Pendant
Steve Madden Cropped Puffer Coat
American Eagle Long Weekend V-Neck Sweater
Abercrombie & Fitch Curve Love Mid Rise Bootcut Jean
JW PEI Tessa Crushed Shoulder Bag - White
This effortless loungewear ensemble
Leave it to Lucy to make lounge clothing look chic. From the sporty track pants to the zip-up sweatshirt and cami combo, I'm pretty sure I pinned this exact outfit in 2011. And of course, you can't forget the Ugg boots; her chestnut-colored pair is timeless.
Aritzia Cozy Sweatfleece Perfect Zip Hoodie
Abercrombie & Fitch Bra-Free Lace-Trim Rib Cami
Tapata Track Pants
UGG Classic II Short Shearling Boots
Project Cloud Genuine Suede Ankle Boots
Lauren Gruber is an commerce editor at Hearst Magazines, where she writes for publications like Good Housekeeping, Cosmopolitan, Prevention, Country Living, House Beautiful, and more. She has over four years of professional experience covering a variety of lifestyle topics from home to fashion, with an advanced background in beauty and fragrance. When she’s not researching the most worthy Prime Day deals or hands-on testing all the latest perfume launches, Lauren is probably hanging out with her cat Serafina or flexing her AMC A-List membership at the movie theater. You can find her previous work at Entertainment Tonight, Shop TODAY, USA Today, Self Magazine, L’Officiel USA, V Magazine, and Modern Luxury Media.
