The 10 Best Organic Pillows to Invest in If You Wanna Get Your *Best* Sleep Ever
Your dreams? They just got sweeter.
We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we love. Promise.
If you wake up in the morning feeling like the star of a Benadryl commercial (you know the look: Watery eyes, congested, rash-ridden, and unbearably achy), it miiight just be time to rethink your current pillow sitch for something a little more natural, dare I even say ~organic~. Think about it: *Ideally* you spend eight hours a night cheek-to-cheek with your pillow. So if you’re resting your delicate lil noggin’ on an old, flat pancake (which BTW is probs FILLED with dust mites and dust mite feces - yuck!) or maybe you opted for a cheaply made pillow from harsh synthetics, it only makes sense why your beauty sleep is taking a serious hit.
“Natural materials like cotton or linen tend to be more breathable than synthetics like polyester. Some consumers also may rest easier knowing they are sleeping on something that doesn't contain any trace elements of harsh chemicals,” says Dr. Shelby Harris, Director of Sleep Health at Sleepopolis, on the many benefits to choosing an organic pillow, adding “some shoppers might look for an organic pillow for environmental benefits. Many synthetic materials used in bedding products are made of plastic, which are primarily derived from fossil fuels like natural gas or petroleum.”
Now, since we are all friends here, I will be completely honest and let you know that truly ~organic~ pillows come with some sticker shock. BUT an organic, quality pillow is absolutely worth the investment for your sleep and health, often lasting much longer than traditional pillows, says Dr. Purvi Parikh, allergist with Allergy & Asthma Network.
So, if you are ready to be blissfully cradled in organic comfort and *maybe* sneeze a little less, keep scrolling to shop the internet’s best naturally made, organic pillows on the market.
Pros
- 3 Density Options
- Responsibly Sourced
- Hypoallergenic
Cons
- Price is steep, but you're worth it, no?
Let me tell you, organic down pillows are v hard to come by. Luckily, I have scoured the internet and came across this plush, feather-filled bad boy. With a 100 percent organic cotton outer and responsibly sourced Canadian down, catching zzz's should be no problem.
Glowing review: Just the right amount of soft. Knowing everything is organic and natural allows me to sleep peacefully knowing I'm not mashing my face in chemicals for 8 hours everyday!
Pros
- Available in four colors
- Includes down pillow Insert
- Machine-washable
Cons
- Final Sale
I just KNOW you would look good lounging on this throw pillow while streaming your latest Netflix obsession. This organic linen cutid only gets softer with use, so kick back and relax! Plus, this plus bb comes with an insert!
Glowing review: Was looking for cushy display pillows in bright colors to accent a mid-century decor and was so happy to find these as an option - the linen fabric was a real bonus and I love them! Large and malleable and striking in orange and citrus.
Pros
- Adjustable filling
- Cotton stays cool
- Free of chemicals
Cons
- Shipping is a bit pricey
Haven't found your cuffing season partner yet? This organic cotton body pillow will do the trick while you continue your search. Made with an organic cotton fill, this pillow is super supportive while providing max comfort. Soooo, it is basically the ideal partner.
Glowing review: We ordered the biggest size body pillow with the cover. The whole thing was solid, packed, and super comfortable! Very huggable! And it smelled nice and clean.
Pros
- Hypoallergenic
- Super Affordable
Cons
- Too firm for some sleepers
- Filling is not from natural fibers
Despite your most recent Whole Foods’ receipt, buying organic does not mean you have to spend a small fortune. At under $20 (!!!) this organic cotton shell pillow with recycled hypoallergenic fiberfill, should be on your bed right TF now.
Glowing review: I was pleasantly surprised with the fullness of these pillows. At times it seems like you have to trade quality for allergy friendly products. It is definitely not the case with these pillows. I suffer from terrible allergies and I am happy to have found pillows that won't cause my sinus to flare up and are extremely full and comfortable.
Pros
- Comes with extra filling so you can adjust to your liking
- 100-Night Trial
- 1-Year Warranty Included
Cons
- Not the traditional U-shape like most travel pillows
Whether you are a part-time jetsetter or just suffer from the occasional stiff neck after a car ride, owning a travel pillow is a must. Consider investing in a super high-quality, organic travel pillow that will take you mile to mile. This one from Avocado def fits the bill to be your new travel companion.
Glowing review: I love this pillow! I just wanted to keep smooshing my face into it. I took it with me on a long international flight, and it was so luxurious to rest upon. The texture outer cotton fabric is heavenly, but I put a pillowcase on to keep it clean. The stuffing level was fine the way it came, and I’m grateful to have extra stuffing for later.
Pros
- 3 Comfort Options
- Allergy-Friendly
- Organic Cotton Shell
Cons
- A lil bit of a splurge
If you aren’t down with down pillows, this bb with a hypoallergenic alternative fill is just what you need. Free from toxins, harmful pesticides, and GMOs, this is a great option for those who suffer from animal allergens.
Glowing review: I bought this pillow after finding out that I have a down allergy, which slowly developed after 30 years of sleeping exclusively on down. I love the feel of down pillows and comforters, and did a lot of research into brands that sell realistic alternatives before placing an order. I'm very pleased with this pillow. It really does feel identical to down. After over a year of use, it hasn't flattened or gotten lumpy.
Pros
- Organic Cotton Filling and Shell
- Cooling
Cons
- A bit firm for some sleepers
Like to stack your pillows for ultimate head and neck support? Or maybe want to attempt being a grown adult with a matching pillow set (don’t worry, the Squishmallows can stay)? This 100% organic cotton, all-natural duo from Wayfair is what dreams are made of. And surprisingly affordable given the high-quality materials used.
Glowing review: My husband and I love them.... I also love that they are made with organic cotton fill and organic cotton material. That was not easy to find! And you get 2 pillows so that is great.
Pros
- Available in a ton of sizes and firmness options
- High Quality
- Sustainably Sourced
Cons
- Slight natural smell from wool
- On the pricier side
This wool option might be a splurge, but think of allll the money you will be saving on Kleenex and allergy meds. Ethically sourced from “happy sheep” in New Zealand, you will have no problem counting sheep as you rest sneeze-free on this naturally dust mite resistant pillow. Bless you, lil sheep!
Glowing review: I bought your wool pillows for my son who suffers from an allergy to dust mites. This was a great solution to the toxic wraps. He absolOOutely loves his pillows and for the first time he can lay his head down without sneezing. He is able to lay on the couch , watch a movie and feel comfortable. All the rest of the family wants them too.
OrganicTextiles 100% Talalay Natural Latex Pillow with Organic Cotton Cover
Pros
- Great for sensitive skin
- Temp regulating
- Eco-friendly
Cons
- Pillow cannot be washed
TBH, I didn’t know latex came from the sap of rubber trees. And, if I am being even more honest, I definitely did not know rubber actually came from trees (kinda embarrassing, NGL). But I do know this natural latex pillow comes highly rated by over 1,000 well-rested Amazon customers and is an eco-friendly, organic alternative to microfiber. Nice!
Glowing review: I wanted to take some time before doing a review on this pillow. I have been using it now for a month, and I can honestly say it is wonderful. I know that a pillow is a very personal thing and I am definitely a fuss pot, but I will say that this has come pretty close to perfect. It is soft but doesn’t smother you, it has enough bounce to make it feel like you’re sleeping on a cloud.
Pros
- Adjustable Filling for Customizable Comfort
- Multiple size options
- Buckwheat hulls allow for air flow
Cons
- Makes a slight rustling sound
Most cooling pillows are made from synthetic plastic materials, which TBH is not very cool. Surprisingly, buckwheat hulls make for an ultra-cool pillow fill that is both organic and supportive. Plus, you can add or take out as much filling as you want, meaning you don’t have to worry about your pillow becoming flat as a (buckwheat) pancake.
Glowing review: The pillow keeps my head cool throughout the night in AZ heat. You can also adjust the pillow to your liking by reducing the amount of buckwheat inside. I ordered one for my daughter and she says it’s the best pillow she ever had!
How to choose an organic pillow
Familiarize yourself with certifications.
When shopping for an organic pillow, Dr. Harris recommends being on the lookout for certifications like Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) and Global Organic Latex Standard (GOLS). These certifications are basically a big thumbs-up in the bedding industry, letting you know the materials have been vetted through a third-party certifier’s strict standards to be classified as organic.
Know your allergens.
To put it plainly, allergies suck. So, the last thing you want to do is drop money on a pillow that irritates the hell out of you. “Many allergy sufferers with sensitive skin suffer from allergies to down, wool, latex and other animals so if an organic pillow contains these items it may actually make your allergies worse,” explains Dr. Parikh. So, if that sounds like you, def consider opting for a hypoallergenic pillow or one made from a sustainable down alternative.
Pay close attention to the materials.
Make sure you are looking for truly natural materials that are organically produced. Unfortunately, manufacturers will add synthetic fillers and fibers, which you def want to avoid. “Remember that a product may feature on material that is certified organic, but there may be other materials used which are not,” adds Dr. Harris.
Don’t be fooled by packaging.
A lot of wannabe organic and natural products come in cute, eco-friendly looking packaging to deceive the customer (aka greenwashing, which I have def fallen victim to). Be a savvy shopper by looking at the fine print, fabric content, and certification logos. You def cannot judge a book by its cover, or a pillow by its packaging for that matter.
How we chose the best organic pillow
As you probably know, Cosmo’s lifestyle team spends all day, every day scouring the internet, testing products, and reading reviews so we can bring you the type of high-quality content we’d want for ourselves (and our standards are preeeetty darn high, TBH).
It’s also really important to us that each of our shopping articles adheres to the 15 Percent Pledge, and we try to make sure the products we feature are good for both you and our planet. If we wouldn’t buy something for ourselves, we sure as heck won’t recommend it to you—and we’re always gonna keep it really, really real. Pinky swear.
Cosmo Editors Love These Burgundy Lipsticks
PSA: Hailey Bieber’s Fave Dry Shampoo Is Only $12
Before You Buy Hair-Growth Supplements, Read This
Where to Next? These Travel Pants Have Me Inspired
