For our Party Tricks challenge, we asked a set of super-creative entertaining experts to show us how they come up with table decor for a themed bash. (Spoiler alert: It starts and ends with Amazon, which makes finding and sourcing everything they could possibly need with ease, and within budget.)

In this episode, Cosmo's own editor in chief, Willa Bennett, stepped up to the plate, with "Y2K dinner soirée" as her theme. She quickly broke the task down to three major components: accessories (as she says, "you can never have too many"), chic glassware to set the proper vibe, and the ever-important gift bags, so every guest walks away with something to remember when they were partying like it was (the year after) 1999.

Watch the video above for all the deets, and shop Willa's picks from Amazon below. And don't miss our Party Tricks series finale, a roundtable featuring all three of our contestants comparing notes. For the whole series, click here.