I Tried Every Single Rare Beauty Product—These Ones are Actually Worth the TikTok Hype

My poor, dry skin hasn’t gotten the memo that winter is over just yet and has been begging and pleading for relief. Thankfully, this body cream exists, and is formulated with shea and jojoba–ingredients that lock in moisture and give this cream its thick, luxe feel. As if that weren’t enough, the scent is super lovely. I smell like a fresh summer peach plucked straight from a flower garden. Low-key, I kinda feel like one too.

• Key ingredients: Murumuru butter, shea butter, jojoba oil, vitamin E, and niacinamide
• Size: 8.45 fl oz
  
• Shades: N/A

One Cosmo editor says: “This is unlike any other body cream I have at home—and I have about 10—all thanks to the whipped, bouncy texture. It's so easy to rub in, immediately absorbs, and leaves my skin feeling extremely hydrated. And the citrus scent is so lovely to wake me up in the morning.” —Beth Gillette, beauty editor

This highlighter is perfect for those of us who want a very natural glow without going full strobe. Dab a bit of this product onto the back of your hand, then pat it onto the high points of your face with a finger to get dewy, healthy-looking skin.

• Key ingredients: Lotus, gardenia, white water lily
• Size: .5 oz
• Shades: 10

One Cosmo editor says: “If you love a two-in-one product, let me put you onto this pigmented highlighter. Like all Rare Beauty cheek products, it's super pigmented, so a little drop goes a long way. This multitasker blends out to a radiant cheek tint, eliminating the need for a blush and highlighter in your makeup kit.” —Jasmine Hyman, assistant beauty editor

Have you been searching for a mascara that is easily buildable without smudging or flaking throughout the day? Well, when you're ready, come and get it (nana na na). Rare's volumizing mascara does just that; while you can achieve very subtle but defined lashes in just a few strokes, continuing to build will lift and separate, creating a more dramatic look. This is also more of a “dry” formula, which helps keep lashes from drooping and being weighed down.

• Key ingredients: Castor oil
• Size: .45 fl oz
• Shades: 1 (black)

One Cosmo editor says: "Applying mascara probably takes the longest out of everything in my makeup routine because I like to build the product up without clumping my lashes together, and Rare’s mascara seems to be made for exactly that. Also, I wore this mascara on a three-hour train ride after working a full eight-hour day, and when I got home and looked in the mirror, it hadn't budged. Selena, I’m begging you: release this in brown!” —JL

A liquid contour in the same packaging as the iconic blush? Sign me up! Thankfully, the contour also has the same incred formula: great pigment, easy to blend, and impressive shade range. TBH, it's actually even creamier, IMO, to help avoid any splotchiness.

• Key ingredients: Hydrogenated polyisobutene, mica
• Size: .5 fl oz
• Shades: 7

One Cosmo editor says: “Okay, I usually hate liquid contour products because they blend out muddy and are never actually cool-toned... but this one seriously changed the game. The formula is so soft on the skin and diffuses out like butter—no patchiness or streaks. The shade range is expansive, and the applicator is super easy to work with too. No notes!” —JH

A product that brightens the appearance of my under eye circles without caking up? Yes, pls! It's worth noting that while this is definitely not full coverage, it significantly improves the appearance of dark under-eye bags. And, as a bonus, the applicator has a metal tip, which is a refreshing cool touch to treat your skin. Not only do my eyes look brighter, but they feel brighter, too. Pro tip: Apply one dot of product under each eye, a bit further down than you typically would, and use your finger to blend the product up towards your eyes for a seamless look.

• Key ingredients: Lotus, gardenia, white water lily
• Size: .25 oz
• Shades: 8
  

One Cosmo editor says: "This product is filed under 'if I ever get pink eye and have to throw out all of my makeup and can only buy a few new things because I'm responsible and won't splurge, I will absolutely be re-purchasing this.' I don't love full-coverage under-eye products because they settle into my fine lines and are incredibly drying. This brightener helps me fake a good night's sleep! One tube lasted me about two years, so it's absolutely worth the money." —JL

With this bronzer, no one will even know you've been hidden in your bedroom cave all winter long! Selena wasn’t kidding when she called this bronzer stick “effortless”; it glides on incredibly easily and blends like a dream. Before the launch of the new liquid contour, many purchased this in a cooler tone for contouring since it's so easy to place exactly where you want it. And, unsurprisingly, this product was also named best bronzer in Cosmo's Readers' Choice Awards.

• Key ingredients: Lotus, gardenia, white water lily
• Size: .25 oz
• Shades: 8

One Cosmo reader says: “The contour is so creamy, and the shade range is awesome."

Selena wasn’t messing around when she named this foundation. As soon as this is applied and blended in, it feels like there’s nothing on my skin. Yet, miraculously, my redness is evened out and my blemishes have all but disappeared. This formula is incredibly buildable; I’ve found that the best way to apply is by dabbing onto the back of my hand, using a finger to tap onto my cheeks, forehead, and chin, and then blend out with a foundation brush.

• Key ingredients: Lotus, gardenia, white water lily
• Size: .94 oz
• Shades: 48

One Cosmo editor says: "This was the first Rare Beauty launch, and from there, I knew I had a new fave brand in my hands. This foundation, now years later, is still one of my go-tos for covering acne and dark spots and evening out my skin tone without feeling like I'm wearing a heavy full-coverage formula. And its got a wide shade range, so I can always find my right match." — BG

This product is a perfect spring/summer lip gloss. It applies and feels like a gloss but is long-lasting like a balm. And, thanks to jojoba and sunflower seed oils, it keeps my lips hydrated long after it’s worn off. I'm partial to Nearly Neutral as my go-to shade, but there are five others to choose from depending on your ~vibes~.

• Key ingredients: Jojoba seed oil, sunflower seed oil
• Size: .12 fl oz
• Shades: 6

One Cosmo editor says: “I’m a big fan of lip gloss, but it’s hard to find one that isn’t sticky and actually keeps my lips hydrated. The Stay Vulnerable Glossy Lip Balm delivers every time. It’s one of the first lip glosses I’ve used all the way until it was completely empty! My favorite shade is Nearly Berry—it gives the perfect amount of color to complement my dark hair.” —Tori Polizzotto, executive assistant

This powder is super light and effortless but definitely helps my makeup stay on longer. It seamlessly sets foundation, concealer, skin tint—whatever—without drying out your face or completely mattifying your shine. It’s also perfect for anyone on the go, thanks to its chic half-moon compact that can be stuffed in virtually any bag.

• Key ingredients: Synthetic fluorphlogopite, calcium carbonate, zinc stearate
• Size: .28 oz
• Shades: 14

One Cosmo editor says: “I have combo skin, and I really struggle to keep my makeup in place all day. But when I use the Rare Beauty powder to set my foundation, I don't have to worry. My makeup stays on all day, even through mask wearing. I can already tell this will be my go-to in the hot summer months.” —Olivia Truffaut-Wong, editor

If you’re looking to add some oomph to your eye look but are hopeless when it comes to smokey eyes (or eyeshadow in general), then this product is perfect for you. Just sweep the crayon across each eye—seriously, it's that easy. You don't even really need to blend it with a brush; instead, smudge the outer corners with your fingers to get rid of any harsh lines.

• Key ingredients: Trisiloxane, synthetic fluorphlogopite, and dimethicone
• Size: .04 oz
• Shades: 6

One Cosmo editor says: “I currently have on the taupe shade "Contentment" as I write this (lol). They're some of the easiest and creamiest eyeshadow sticks I own to quickly smudge all over my lids before work, but still make me look put together.” —BG