The Traitors is back and more devious than ever! And the show revealed a new twist for Season 4: Alan Cumming picked a "Secret Traitor," whose identity was a mystery to everyone—including the audience. That is, until episode three, when their identity was revealed to be....

SPOILER AHEAD!

the traitors "let the cards fall as they will" episode 401 pictured: secret traitor (photo by: euan cherry/peacock)
Peacock

Donna Kelce. Unexpected! The thing is, we saw glimpses of the Secret Traitor wandering around Alan's castle in a dramatic red cloak, and a fan on Reddit paused the show at the exact moment that showed part of their face—revealing a mustached man. Very much not Donna Kelce.

This obviously means the show uses members of the production team to stage some of the b-roll, and that nope: they didn't make Donna put on a Little Red Riding Hood cloak and wander up and down a bunch of stairs. It's also a pretty genius move on the part of the show, because it means we can no longer try to figure out who people are based on their height and build!

Anyway, Donna's Secret Traitor identity was found out during the round table in Episode 3. Upon leaving, she said "playing a Traitor was tough, but I gave it my best shot. This has been a dream come true. These are happy tears that I get to do this at this point in my life. It’s just the joy of being in the game."

Love her.