Craig Conover is “all in” on his budding romance with content creator Natalie Buffett. Sources spilled to Us Weekly all about the latest development in the Southern Charm star’s love life, and it seems like he’s moved on from his split with Paige DeSorbo.
While fans were recently (and unofficially) introduced to Natalie, her connection with Craig actually dates back to 2019. Meaning: the pair met long before Paige was even in the picture. According to an insider, “Craig and Natalie met years ago and had a fling” that was “brief and not good timing.”
They reportedly met through mutual friends and reconnected in February. The source added, “Craig wasn’t in a spot to date anyone seriously but loved reconnecting with her,” and that he “always believes in signs and things working out if they are meant to be.”
“They are taking things slow and it’s still pretty new, but Craig is all in,” the source continued, adding that they had been seeing each other for a few months between Charleston and New York City. While Natalie “travels often,” the Texas native “spends time” in New York and Florida.
Oh, and the insider dished that Craig “loves that Natalie likes being low-key with him and they have been having fun together.”
“Everyone around him is happy that he is happy,” they said, explaining that he’s been in “great spirits after a really rough breakup and his friends are supporting him.”
The Sewing Down South was previously linked to Summer House star and Giggly Squad podcast host Paige for three years before they ended things at the end of last year. In another report, sources spilled how she really feels about her ex’s new romance, saying, “Paige isn’t fazed by Craig dating.” They also noted that she “doesn’t have time” to think about Craig “when she’s busy with work and her own personal life.”
As for Natalie, she dated Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott from 2020 to 2022 and eventually moved on with MLB pitcher for the Detroit Tigers, Jack Flaherty, before they called it quits in 2024. Us Weekly recently confirmed that she and Craig were an item in March 2025.
