It’s a good day for a Blind Date Season 2 premiere! Quick refresher: the interview series sends Cosmopolitan editor-in-chief Willa Bennett on (blind) first dates with everyone’s favorite celebs. Last season, Willa turned on the charm for everyone from Reneé Rapp to Manny Jacinto, so clearly there was a high bar going into the second season. Enter the internet’s forever boyfriend: Logan Lerman.

Logan has been locked down and fiancé-d for a minute now but even so, he was up for a chat about dating and relationships once Willa knew who he was. She initially guessed fellow faves Drew Starkey and Troye Sivan (Logan said Troye was a "close guess") but once Logan revealed he had recently worked with Molly Gordon, Willa immediately knew it was the Oh, Hi! star.

They talked through the basics—like whether Logan is daddy or mother, and Martin Short’s banjo playing on the Only Murders in the Building set—and advised the best way to rule the dating apps is to include photos with your pets, which we… have strong views about. If there’s anything you should know about Logan after this episode, though, it’s that he’d actually be completely into role-playing as Percy Jackson in bed. The more you know! Watch the full episode above to hear more on that (among other things).